A Turning Point in the Pharmacy Landscape: What Employer Plan Sponsors Need to Know

By Erin Powell, RHU® | Seubert Compliance Officer

Employer plan sponsors are facing a fundamental shift in the pharmacy benefits landscape driven by two major developments:

The FTC / Express Scripts settlement, and
The PBM reform provisions in the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2026 (CAA 2026).

Together, these changes significantly expand transparency, accountability, and fiduciary risk for employer-sponsored group health plans.

FTC / Express Scripts Settlement: Enforcement Has Arrived

The FTC’s settlement with Express Scripts signals a clear message:
PBM practices are no longer just contractual issues—they are regulatory risks.

Key implications for employer plan sponsors:

PBMs must substantiate pricing and reimbursement practices
Certain steering and exclusionary behaviors are under heightened scrutiny
The FTC has established a roadmap for future PBM enforcement actions

While the settlement applies directly to the PBM, employer plans that adopt or tolerate opaque PBM arrangements may face increased fiduciary exposure.

For more information about FTC/Express Scripts settlement click here.

CAA of 2026: PBM Reform Becomes Mandatory

The CAA of 2026 codifies PBM reform into federal law, imposing new statutory obligations on group health plans, including:

Expanded PBM compensation and fee disclosures
Enhanced drug cost transparency
New PBM reporting and notice requirements
Stronger alignment with ERISA fiduciary standards

Unlike prior transparency rules, these requirements are not optional and cannot be delegated away.

Under ERISA, employer plan sponsors remain responsible—even when vendors perform the reporting.

For more information about CAA of 2026 PBM Reform click here.

For a comparison between both the FTC Settlement and CAA of 2026 PBM Reform click here.

Reach out to Seubert today to begin renegotiating your pharmacy contract, ensuring complete transparency and unlocking maximum savings.

Erin is the Compliance Officer in Seubert’s Employee Benefits Department. She joined Seubert in 2008 and has more than 17 years of experience in the employee benefits and compliance industry. In her current role, Erin is responsible for ensuring awareness of new developments and/or changes in the various federal and state laws that may impact a business’ employee benefits program.

Compliance

Employee Benefits

Recent News

How Commercial Insurance Applications Affect Your Coverage

When businesses purchase commercial insurance, they often focus on limits, deductibles and policy terms. Yet the insurance application is equally important. It is a legal document insurers use to evaluate risk, determine eligibility and establish coverage terms and pricing.

Seubert Celebrates 10 Years on Pittsburgh’s North Shore

Seubert & Associates celebrates 10 years at its Pittsburgh North Shore headquarters with a look at its growth and newly renovated office.

Employee Spotlight: Mariah Gigler

Please join us in welcoming Mariah Gigler to the Seubert Team!

DOL Proposes to Expand Electronic Delivery Options for Group Health Plans

On July 23, 2026, the U.S. DOL issued a proposed rule that would establish a new, additional safe harbor for group health plan administrators to use electronic media to furnish plan disclosures required under the ERISA.

Employee Spotlight: Delany Graff

Please join us in welcoming Delany Graff to Seubert’s Admin Department as an Accounting Clerk!

Compliance Update: Federal Agencies Issue FAQs Addressing Key Issues in Health Plan Tobacco Surcharge Lawsuits

Federal agencies have issued new FAQ guidance addressing two issues at the center of tobacco surcharge class-action lawsuits: when the full wellness program reward must be provided, and what employee notice is required. Here’s what employers need to know.